Loud Thinking

Miltablishment’s End Game

Najam Sethi
TFT 15 August, 2014.

It isn’t a coincidence that Imran Khan has woken up a year after the elections to contest their wholesale legitimacy and demand the ouster of the Nawaz Sharif government while Tahir ul Qadri has simultaneously leapt out of far-away Canada to demand nothing less than a “revolution” to change the political system. Nor is it pure political opportunism that has compelled Imran Khan to constantly change the goal posts of his “azadi march” from a recount of votes in four Lahore constituencies, to the resignations of the four provincial election commissioners, to a reconstitution of the Election Commission and a reframing of electoral laws, to the establishment of a Supreme Court body for investigation into charges of electoral fraud and legitimacy, ending up with nothing less than regime change as a prelude to all of the above.

Both Imran Khan and Tahir ul Qadri have demonstrated links with the military establishment, or “Miltablishment”, dating back to the Musharraf-Pasha era. This powerful military establishment is now separate from and distinct from the defunct notion of the “Establishment” which denoted the military-bureaucratic steel-frame that once ruled Pakistan before the politicians corrupted and politicized the civil bureaucracy and co-opted it on their side. This agenda has been facilitated by the Chaudhries of Gujrat and Sheikh Rashid of Lal Haveli who are self-avowed proxies of the “Miltablishment”.

The “Miltablishment’s” aggressive but indirect interventionism in the political system stems from the potential tilting of power from the military to the civilians as electoral democracy has taken root internally and the external prop of the military in the form of the United States has withdrawn from the region. It first flexed its muscle during the Kayani era when the PPP government was straightjacketed and compelled to concede on all issues of “national security” as exclusively defined by GHQ-ISI. Now it has moved decisively to cut Nawaz Sharif to size after his decision to seize control of, and redefine, “national security” policy, especially as relates to regional foreign policy and ant-terrorism strategy. Mr Sharif’s decision to try ex-army chief Musharraf for treason has raised the hackles of the Miltablishment and compelled it to strike back.

This is to say that the Miltablishment’s preferred strategy now is to remain in control of the commanding heights of “national security” by making new allies in the media and even judiciary, both of which now claim “independent” status as organs of the state, to compensate for the abdication of the civil bureaucracy and loss of power to the representatives of the electorate.

This helps to explain not just the current movement for “azadi” or “revolution” by the political allies and proxies of the Miltablishment but also the critical role of the “new media” from the corporate sector in sustaining this development (The Jang/Geo Group is getting the stick because it belongs to the old media which is hamstrung by notions of “journalistic” independence.)

More significantly, it helps to explain how the Miltablishment intends to steer the ongoing political turmoil to its advantage in the next few weeks. A Zia-ist coup is not on the table. Equally, a Kakarist shove can be ruled out because the Nawaz Sharif of 2014 is temperamentally poles apart from the Nawaz Sharif of 1993. This leaves the Kayani option on the table. If Nawaz Sharif, Iftikhar Chaudhry and the old media were key allies in the game to make Zardari politically impotent, then Imran Khan, Tahir ul Qadri and the new media are allies today in the game to cut Sharif down to size. This is to say that the dogs of war will be called off from besieging Islamabad after Sharif concedes the demand to investigate the elections of 2013 via the Supreme Court, reconstitutes the Election Commission with the approval of the chief protagonists immediately, lets Musharraf off the hook, backtracks on his regional foreign policy initiatives and commits to dissolving parliament and holding fresh elections if the SC so directs on the basis of its findings.

Needless to say, however, the best-laid plans can go awry when these are subject to unpredictable mass crowd behavior. Any deviation from the script by Imran Khan and/or Tahir ul Qadri in the heat of the moment can have unintended consequences no less than the premeditated provocation of terrorists. Certainly, after a series of miscalculations – starting with the Model Town incident and the stop-go measures to close and open the routes for the long marchers and the stubborn refusal to open negotiations with Imran Khan on his core issues some months ago – the Sharifs cannot afford to ride on their high horses any more. They have lost their foothold and standing and will be totally dependent on the goodwill and support of the Miltablishment to complete their term. Those who have pulled out the demagogues of today and also reigned them in can all too easily pull them out again, should the need arise, for a more decisive round in the future.

Twitter message of Imran Khan.

@ImranKhanPTI:

The dharna venue is Kashmir Highway Serena Chowk. I am near the airport and arriving at the venue soon InshaAllah.

“We do not heal the past by dwelling there; we heal the past by living fully in the present.”

— Marianne Williamson

MOST WICKETS AGAINST PAKISTAN

Player Mat Wkts Ave. 5wkt

N Kapil Dev India
29 99 30.12 7

SK Warne Aus
15 90 20.17 6

A Kumble India
15 81 31.97 5

GD McGrath Aus
17 80 21.70 3

M Muralitharan SL
16 80 25.46 5

HMRKB Herath SL
17 79 30.31 5

DK Lillee Aus
17 71 30.43 5

CA Walsh WI
18 63 23.04 4

Sir RJ Hadlee NZ
12 51 28.39 4

CEH Croft WI
9 50 19.56 1

“To put the world right in order, we must first put the nation in order; to put the nation in order, we must first put the family in order; to put the family in order, we must first cultivate our personal life; we must first set our hearts right.”

—Confucius (551-479)
Philosopher

General Raheel Sharif has appreciated the successful action of the all Pak security forces in foiling the attempt of the terrorists to damage the installations at the 2 Quetta airbases.

Any appreciation from the PM???

Silence of Jamaat Islami on the PMLN attack on PTI caravan, its leadership and workers is very meaningful and deafening..!

SHABASH Siraj ul Haq….

“Go into the world and do well. But more importantly, go into the world and do good.”

—Minor Myers Jr. (1942-2003)
Author, Scholar, Composer

“Some people are talking about you just because their lives are boring. Don’t respond. Keep living your life.”

— Thema Davis

Here comes articles 62 and 63..!

Unique decision

By From the Newspaper
Published about 3 hours ago

THE election tribunal in Karachi declared on Aug 11 the election of a member of the National Assembly (NA-211) void and held that the winning candidate was “not sagacious, righteous, non-profligate, honest and Ameen”(Aug 12).

Isn’t it a unique decision with possibly far-reaching effects as most of the members of present assemblies are likely to be disqualified if this decision is taken as a precedent?

Niaz Kaim Khani

Karachi

Published in Dawn, August 14th, 2014

Comment Email Print